Part 2019-2020

  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Warren’s Education Plan, and Why High-Stakes Testing Seems Here to Stay

Warren’s Education Plan, and Why High-Stakes Testing Seems Here to Stay

Posted by Sherwood Steidl on October 26, 2019
Warren’s Education Plan, and Why High-Stakes Testing Seems Here to Stay

At one point in the 2015 negotiations, Ms. Warren voted against a version of the bill because, she later said, it lacked “minimum safeguards” and needed “stronger accountability” to ensure that federal dollars reached “those schools and students who needed them most.” It was a view of accountability substantially based on standardized tests.

A protracted debate over language threatened to scuttle the whole deal. Obama administration officials wanted tests to be the “primary” method of measuring school success. Republicans and the teachers’ unions pushed back. The final compromise allowed states to include several additional measures in their school ratings, including high school graduation rates and metrics of student growth on tests, which give credit when scores improve but still fall short of proficiency.

Each of these indicators must be given “substantial weight” and, collectively, “much greater” weight than another set of newly added indicators that include measures of school safety and student “engagement.”

That’s why Senator Warren’s use of the phrases “significant factor” and “high-stakes decisions” could be, in theory, a big deal. “Significant” sounds a lot like “substantial,” and the identification of low-performing schools for interventions and penalties is generally what people mean when they refer to, or call for the elimination of, “high-stakes testing.”

And yet, when pressed on this question, the Warren campaign repeatedly declined to confirm that those words mean what they seem to mean. A Warren aide, speaking on condition of anonymity, would not say that the Warren plan changes or undoes the 2015 compromise. Instead, the aide referred back to the specific examples cited in the plan, saying that Ms. Warren does not believe tests should be used to close schools or fire teachers.

That means the Warren plan, if enacted, would change very little, because standardized tests are hardly ever used to close schools or fire teachers today. According to Chad Aldeman, an analyst at Bellwether Education Partners, only 231 of the nation’s 98,000 public schools were taken over by the state because of bad test scores during the No Child Left Behind years. Of those, nearly 80 percent were in a single state, Hawaii, which lacks local school districts to do the taking over. Fewer still were converted to charter schools. Even after the Obama administration pushed states to create teacher evaluation systems that incorporated some test data, real-world examples of test-driven systems being used to fire teachers are practically nonexistent.

Two-thirds of public school parents say there is “too much emphasis” on standardized tests in their community’s schools. Nearly half believe parents should be able to excuse their children from taking such tests, a sentiment fueling the testing “Opt Out” movement in New York and elsewhere. President Obama called for a cap on the amount of time students spend taking tests, a move Ms. Warren supported.

Related Song or Videos

Although it's easy to get started with Senator Elizabeth Warren's college plan would cost $1.25 trillion over 10 years

2.88 MB | 2:06

Once a person has decided that they want to get Elizabeth Warren's plan for universal free college and student loan debt

2.7 MB | 1:58

Capturing these moments of the Elizabeth Warren's Education Plan Would Cancel up to $50k in Student Loan Debt

1.33 MB | 0:58

Although it's easy to get started with Elizabeth Warren has a plan for student debt

2.4 MB | 1:45

Once a person has decided that they want to get Elizabeth Warren looks to erase student loan debt

6.41 MB | 4:40

Once a person has decided that they want to get Warren reveals $800B K-12 education plan

3.57 MB | 2:36

It will becomes easier and more convenient to Democrats Pitch Education Plans to Biggest U.S. Teachers Union

181.57 MB | 2:12:13

It will becomes easier and more convenient to Ben Stein: Warren’s free college plan is highly irresponsible

3.43 MB | 2:30

Okay so let's talk about How 2020 candidates plan to tackle $1.56 trillion in student loan debt

6.07 MB | 4:25

The first step to this is FIRST WOMAN PRESIDENT: Elizabeth Warren Says She Has What It Takes

11.24 MB | 8:11

There are many tasks have become challenging Elizabeth Warren using policy proposals to stand out in crowded Democratic field

10.28 MB | 7:29

There are several good reasons about Elizabeth Warren's Universal Child Care Plan

3.41 MB | 2:29

Your curiosity has nearly gotten the best of you Student loans weighing you down? Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren want to get rid of them.

4.44 MB | 3:14

There are many tasks have become challenging Should student debt be erased?

14.97 MB | 10:54

It will becomes easier and more convenient to Sen. Warren Unveils Massive $1.25T Plan To Tackle Student Debt, $640B In Debt Forgiveness

9.82 MB | 7:09

Although it's easy to get started with Dave Ramsey's Thoughts On Sen. Warren's Student Loan Solution

7.37 MB | 5:22

Okay so let's talk about Elizabeth Warren's plan to protect our democracy

2.06 MB | 1:30

I have come to the conclusion that Sen. Elizabeth Warren proposes major student loan relief plan

1.17 MB | 0:51

For going further into this article, the following Elizabeth Warren on why we should tax the ultra-rich to fund education

15.72 MB | 11:27